Discount break-even calculator
How many more orders does 10% off, $5 off or free shipping need before it makes as much profit as full price? Enter your price and costs — the answer updates as you type and includes payment fees and refunds.
More costs (payment fees, refunds) and test sizing
Extra orders needed at each discount
Same price and costs as above, different % off.
| Discount | Profit per order | Extra orders needed |
|---|---|---|
| 5% off | $17.70 | +10.4% |
| 10% off | $15.86 | +23.2% |
| 15% off | $14.01 | +39.4% |
| 20% off | $12.17 | +60.5% |
| 25% off | $10.33 | +89.2% |
| 30% off | $8.49 | +130.2% |
| 40% off | $4.80 | +306.7% |
| 50% off | $1.12 | +1644.6% |
A discount breaks even when the extra orders it brings make up for the profit it gives away on every order. Extra orders needed = profit per order today ÷ profit per order with the discount − 1. With a $40 product, $12 cost, $5 shipping, 2.9% + 0.30 fees and 5% refunds, 10% off needs 23% more orders, 20% off needs 61% more, and 30% off needs 130% more.
The formula
Profit per order is what you keep after everything that grows with each order: price after the offer, minus product cost, shipping you pay, payment fees (charged on the discounted price) and refunds (a refunded order loses the product cost and shipping). Fixed costs such as rent or apps don't change with one more order, so they are left out. The quick shortcut with margins as a share of the original price is discount ÷ (margin − discount).
Worked example. $40 price, $12 cost, $5 shipping paid by you, 2.9% + $0.30 fees, 5% refunds. Today: $38.00 kept after refunds − $12.00 product − $5.00 shipping − $1.46 fees = $19.54 per order. At 10% off ($36): $34.20 − $12.00 − $5.00 − $1.34 = $15.86. 19.54 ÷ 15.86 − 1 = +23.2% more orders to stand still.
What the result means
- Below the line, you lose money while sales go up. If the offer brings 15% more orders and you needed 23%, revenue rises and profit falls.
- Free shipping is a discount too. It gives up the shipping charge on every order, including the ones that would have bought anyway.
- Prove it before you keep it. A lift this size takes thousands of visitors per group to detect. With too little traffic, a test can't tell a paying discount from a losing one — run longer or test a bigger change.
Questions
How do I calculate how many more sales a discount needs?
Work out the profit you keep on one order today and with the discount, after product cost, shipping, payment fees and refunds. Divide today's profit per order by the discounted profit per order and subtract 1. That is the extra orders you need just to earn the same total profit. Example: $19.54 today and $15.86 at 10% off → 19.54 ÷ 15.86 − 1 = 23.2% more orders.
Is there a quick formula for the break-even sales increase?
Yes: required increase = discount ÷ (margin − discount), with both as a percent of the original price and margin meaning what you keep after all variable costs. With a 49% contribution margin, 10% off needs 10 ÷ (49 − 10) ≈ 26% more orders. Payment fees shrink with the price, which is why the calculator's exact answer is a little lower.
Why does a small discount need so many extra sales?
The discount comes straight out of your profit, not out of the price. On a $40 product that keeps about $20 after costs, $4 off removes a fifth of the profit, so you need roughly a quarter more orders to make it back. The thinner the margin, the faster the requirement grows — at 40–50% off it often becomes impossible.
Is free shipping cheaper than a percentage discount?
Only if the shipping charge you drop is smaller than the discount you would otherwise give. Free shipping removes the shipping fee the customer pays you on every order. Switch the offer to Free shipping and compare the extra orders needed with the % off result on the same costs.
Does this include Shopify payment fees and refunds?
Yes. Payment fees are charged on the price after the discount (default 2.9% + 0.30, a typical online card rate — use your own plan's rate), and refunded orders are assumed to lose the product cost and shipping you paid. Change both under More costs.
How do I know if my discount actually reached break-even?
Run the offer as a split test and compare conversion between the two groups. The calculator shows how many visitors each group needs to detect a lift as large as the break-even lift (5% significance, 80% power) and how many days that takes at your traffic. If you cannot reach that sample, the test cannot tell you whether the discount paid.
Do it on your real numbers
Evenline is a Shopify app that runs this calculation on each product's real cost from Shopify and your refund rate from recent orders, covers free-shipping thresholds and multi-buy offers, plans the test (sample size and run time from your traffic) and reviews the result against the break-even line. Free for one product.
Install free on the Shopify App StoreDiscounts tested in the table: 5%, 10%, 15%, 20%, 25%, 30%, 40%, 50%. Calculations run in your browser; nothing you type is stored.